Your 19 ACT Score Isn’t a Wall, It’s a Door: A Strategist’s Guide to Finding Your Perfect College Fit

I’ll never forget the phone call from Alex.

He was a brilliant kid, passionate about environmental science, with a transcript that showed a clear upward trend and extracurriculars that screamed dedication.

But his voice was flat, defeated.

He had just gotten his ACT score back: a 19.

“It’s over,” he said.

“All those schools I dreamed of…

it’s just not going to happen.”

In his mind, that number wasn’t a data point; it was a wall.

A final judgment that had slammed shut the doors to his future.

I’ve been a college admissions strategist for over a decade, and I’ve heard that same panic in the voices of countless students and parents.

They see a single number and believe the story ends there.

But my experience has taught me that this is the single biggest mistake a student can make.

My real epiphany came years ago when I realized my job wasn’t just to hand students lists of “safety schools.” It was to fundamentally reframe their understanding of the entire admissions landscape.

The process isn’t a single, high-stakes lock that only a few perfect keys can open.

It’s a massive building with thousands of doors, each with a different kind of lock.

That’s when I developed what I call the “Keys and Doors” paradigm, a framework that has turned anxiety into action for hundreds of families.

It’s simple:

• Your Score is a Key: A 19 on the ACT is a key. It won’t open every door—no single key does—but it will fit a surprising number of locks perfectly. Our first job is to find those doors.
• Some Doors Don’t Need That Key: The test-optional revolution has thrown open thousands of doors. For these, your test score key is irrelevant; you get in based on other strengths.
• You Can Build a Master Key: A powerful, holistic application—your story, your growth, your impact—is a master key that you forge yourself. It can open doors you never thought possible.
• There Are Secret Passages: The community college transfer pathway isn’t a lesser option; it’s a brilliant, strategic route that often leads to the exact same room as the front door, sometimes with even better preparation.

This guide will walk you through this exact framework.

We will dismantle the panic, analyze the data, and build a powerful, personalized strategy.

By the end, you won’t see a wall.

You’ll see a keychain full of options and a map to your future.

Part 1: Understanding Your Key: What a 19 ACT Score Really Means

The moment you see a score like 19, your brain might scream “below average” or “not good enough.” This feeling is real, but it’s based on a perception that isn’t fully aligned with the data.

Let’s replace that panic with perspective.

The Panic vs. The Percentile

First, let’s ground ourselves in the numbers.

A composite score of 19 on the ACT places you in the 44th percentile nationally.¹

This means you scored higher than 44% of the nearly 2 million students who take the test each year.¹

But here is the most critical piece of information that should immediately lower your anxiety: the national average composite score for the high school class of 2024 was 19.4.⁴

Your score of 19 is not some distant outlier; it is almost exactly the statistical average for the entire country.

The gap between feeling like a failure and realizing you are statistically average is where anxiety lives.

By understanding this single fact, you can shift your mindset from “I failed” to “I have an average score, which is a starting point, not an endpoint.”

The Context That Changes Everything: Why Your State Matters

A score of 19 does not have the same value everywhere.

Its significance changes dramatically depending on the state you live in.

This is because some states require every single high school senior to take the ACT, while in other states, only the most competitive, college-bound students choose to take it.

Consider this:

• In states with 100% participation, like Alabama, Mississippi, and Nevada, the testing pool includes students who may not be planning to attend a four-year university. This naturally brings the state’s average score down. In 2024, Alabama’s average was 18.0, and Nevada’s was 17.2.⁴ In this context, a score of 19 is actually
  above average, making you a more competitive applicant for in-state public universities.
• In states with low participation, like Massachusetts, California, and Connecticut, the testing pool is self-selecting. It’s composed primarily of high-achieving students aiming for the nation’s most selective colleges. This artificially inflates the average. Massachusetts’ average score was 26.1.⁴

Your score is not a fixed value; it is relative to the applicant pool that colleges in your region are most familiar with.

Understanding your state’s average provides crucial context for building a realistic and strategic list of in-state and regional schools.

Measuring Against the Benchmarks: A Diagnostic, Not a Judgment

The ACT organization sets College Readiness Benchmarks to indicate a student’s likelihood of success in first-year college courses.

The benchmarks are:

• English: 18
• Math: 22
• Reading: 22
• Science: 23 ⁴

A student with a composite score of 19 has very likely met or exceeded the English benchmark, which is a fantastic signal of foundational writing and communication skills.

You may, however, be below the benchmarks in the other three areas.

This should not be seen as a judgment on your intelligence.

Instead, view it as a helpful diagnostic tool.

It signals to you, and to the colleges you apply to, which subjects might require more support or an introductory-level course in your first year.

This isn’t about barring entry; it’s about setting you up for success once you arrive on campus.

Your score becomes less of a gatekeeper and more of a guidepost for your academic journey.

Part 2: Finding Doors Your Key Fits: A Curated List of Colleges for a 19 ACT

Now that we understand the key we’re holding, let’s find the doors it’s designed to open.

The biggest secret to this process lies in understanding how colleges report their admissions data.

How to Read a College Profile: The “Middle 50%” Secret

When you look up a college’s admissions statistics, you will almost always see the “middle 50%” or “25th-75th percentile” range for the ACT scores of their admitted students.⁸

Let’s say a school you like has a middle 50% range of 20-26.

Your first instinct, holding a 19, might be to cross that school off your list.

This is a mistake born from a misunderstanding of what that range means.

If the middle 50% of admitted students scored between 20 and 26, that means, by definition, that 25% of the students they accepted scored below a 20.

A full quarter of their incoming freshman class had a score like yours or lower.

Your 19 doesn’t disqualify you; it places you squarely in the running, especially if the other parts of your application are strong.

This single realization can dramatically expand your list of potential colleges.

Table 1: Excellent “Likely Fit” Colleges (Where a 19 is in the heart of the middle 50%)

These are institutions where your score of 19 places you comfortably within the typical range of admitted students.

They represent strong, confidence-building options to anchor your college list.

University Name	State	Acceptance Rate	Middle 50% ACT Range
Clark Atlanta University	GA	58%	18–21 10
Alabama A&M University	AL	90%	17–22 10
Fort Valley State University	GA	90%	17–21 10
University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff	AR	82%	16–20 10
Southwestern College	KS	70%	19 (Average) 1

Table 2: Great “Target” Colleges (Where a 19 is in the 25th percentile range)

For these schools, your ACT score is right around the 25th percentile mark, meaning you are a viable candidate.

At these institutions, the strength of your grades, essay, and extracurriculars will be what makes the difference.

University Name	State	Acceptance Rate	Middle 50% ACT Range
Texas State University	TX	89%	19–26 11
Georgia State University	GA	52%	19–26 11
San Francisco State University	CA	94%	18–24 10
Kennesaw State University	GA	Not Listed	19–26 13
Sam Houston State University	TX	Not Listed	18–23 8
University of Montana	MT	Not Listed	18–26 8
University of Memphis	TN	Not Listed	18–24 13

Table 3: High-Acceptance Rate & Open Admission Universities

Building a strategic safety net is crucial for reducing stress.

These quality universities have high acceptance rates, and a student with a 19 ACT and a solid GPA is very likely to be admitted.

Knowing you have these excellent options allows you to apply to your target schools with much greater confidence.

University Name	State	Acceptance Rate
University of Mississippi	MS	98% 14
Arizona State University	AZ	90% 15
Michigan State University	MI	88% 16
University of Arizona	AZ	87% 16
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee	WI	86% 1
Boise State University	ID	84% 14
Towson University	MD	83% 17

Part 3: Building a Master Key: The Test-Optional & Holistic Review Revolution

If finding schools that accept a 19 is about using the key you have, this next strategy is about choosing when not to use it at all.

For a student with an average ACT score, the test-optional movement is the single most powerful strategic advantage available.

Over 2,000 accredited, bachelor’s degree-granting colleges and universities now have test-optional or test-free admission policies.¹⁸

This isn’t about hiding a score; it’s about strategically choosing to highlight the parts of your application where you truly shine.

First, let’s clarify the terms:

• Test-Optional: You choose whether to submit scores. If you do, they are considered as one part of your application. If you don’t, you are not penalized, and more weight is placed on your other materials.¹⁹
• Test-Blind (or Test-Free): The college will not look at ACT or SAT scores at all, even if you send them. The entire University of California and California State University systems, for example, are test-free.²¹
• Test-Flexible: A less common policy where schools might accept other scores, like those from AP or IB exams, in place of the ACT or SAT.²⁴

To Submit or Not to Submit? A Simple Framework

This is the most common question I get from students, and the answer lies in a simple, data-driven framework.

The goal of your application is to present the strongest possible case for your admission.

A data point that is significantly lower than the average for a school’s admitted class can weaken your case.²⁴

Here is the rule:

1. Look up the “middle 50%” ACT range for every test-optional school on your list.
2. If your score is at or above the 50th percentile (the median/midpoint of that range), it will likely help or be neutral. Consider sending it.
3. If your score is at or below the 25th percentile of that range, it is a liability. You should almost certainly choose not to submit it.

The Fine Print: Be aware that some schools, while test-optional for admission, may still use test scores for placement in freshman math and English courses or for consideration for specific merit scholarships.¹⁹

Always check the admissions website for each specific school to understand their full policy.

Crafting Your Holistic Application: The Four Pillars of Your Story

When you withhold a test score, its weight is redistributed to the other components of your application.

This is your opportunity to tell a compelling, coherent story about who you are.

• Pillar 1: Your Academic Narrative: This is about more than your GPA. Admissions officers look for an upward grade trend, which demonstrates maturity and growth. They also look for rigor. Did you challenge yourself by taking the AP, IB, or honors courses that were available at your high school? Earning a B in a difficult AP class is often more impressive than an easy A in a standard-level course.²⁷
• Pillar 2: Your Personal Narrative (The Essay): This is your one chance to speak directly to the admissions committee in your own voice. It’s where you provide the context for your life and your numbers. An essay about overcoming a challenge—whether it was struggling in a tough class, dealing with a family issue, or learning a new skill—can be incredibly powerful. It showcases resilience, problem-solving, and character, turning a potential weakness into a story of strength and perseverance.²⁷
• Pillar 3: Your Impact (Extracurriculars): The key here is depth over breadth. Colleges are more impressed by a sustained, meaningful commitment to one or two activities than a long list of clubs you simply attended. Show how you took initiative, demonstrated leadership, and made a tangible impact on your team, club, or community.³²
• Pillar 4: Your Champions (Letters of Recommendation): Choose teachers who know you well and can speak to your character, work ethic, and growth. A glowing letter from a teacher in a subject where you initially struggled but worked hard to improve is often more powerful than a generic letter from a teacher in a class where you coasted to an A.²⁷

Table 4: A Selection of Excellent Test-Optional & Test-Free Universities

Withholding your score doesn’t limit you.

In fact, it opens up a world of possibilities at some of the most respected universities in the country.

University Name	Location	Test Policy (Fall 2025)
University of Chicago	Chicago, IL	Test-Optional (Permanent) 21
Columbia University	New York, NY	Test-Optional (Permanent) 21
Northwestern University	Evanston, IL	Test-Optional 34
Vanderbilt University	Nashville, TN	Test-Optional (Through Fall 2027) 34
University of Michigan	Ann Arbor, MI	Test-Optional (Through Fall 2026) 34
Williams College	Williamstown, MA	Test-Optional 34
University of California System	CA	Test-Free (Permanent) 21
California State University System	CA	Test-Free (Permanent) 21
Wake Forest University	Winston-Salem, NC	Test-Optional (Permanent) 21
New York University	New York, NY	Test-Optional 34

Part 4: The Secret Passage: Why the Community College Pathway is a Genius Move

For too long, community college has been stigmatized as a “backup plan.” I want you to reframe it as a strategic launchpad.

The “2+2 model”—completing two years at a community college and then transferring to a four-year university to finish your bachelor’s degree—is one of the most financially savvy and academically sound strategies available.³⁶

The Uncomfortable Truth and the Strategic Solution

It is important to be honest about the statistics.

While around 80% of students who start at a community college intend to earn a bachelor’s degree, the reality is that only about a third of them successfully transfer, and only 14-16% of the original group earn a bachelor’s within six years.³⁷

These numbers are not an indictment of community colleges.

They are an indictment of a lack of strategy.

Students often enroll without a clear plan, take courses that don’t transfer, lose credits and motivation, and ultimately fall short of their goal.

The solution is a proactive, strategic approach from day one.

This involves three non-negotiable steps:

1. Prioritize Articulation Agreements: Choose a community college that has formal, guaranteed transfer agreements with the four-year universities you are targeting.
2. Use Transfer Equivalency Tools: From your very first semester, use online tools like Transferology or the specific transfer planners provided by universities (like Texas State’s) to map out every single course you take, ensuring it will count toward your degree.⁴¹
3. Complete Your Associate’s Degree First: Research consistently shows that students who earn an associate’s degree before they transfer have significantly higher bachelor’s degree completion rates.³⁷

The Ultimate Proof: The Transfer Advantage at Selective Schools

Here is the most powerful, counter-intuitive fact that validates this entire pathway: Community college students who successfully transfer to selective four-year institutions have graduation rates that are equal to or even higher than students who enrolled directly from high school.⁴⁴

This demonstrates that transfer students are often more mature, motivated, resilient, and better prepared for the rigors of university academics.

This single data point should eliminate any doubt about the validity of this strategic path.

Table 5: Community Colleges with Open Admissions & Strong Transfer Support

These institutions are designed to be accessible and are known for providing explicit support to students who plan to transfer.

College Name	State	Key Feature
Austin Community College	TX	Open admissions policy; “Bats to Cats” seamless transfer program to Texas State University.45
Montcalm Community College	MI	“Open door” institution providing educational opportunities for all; dedicated transfer options and support.46
Springfield Technical Community College	MA	Open access policy to reduce barriers; over 400 transfer options to four-year colleges.47
Hagerstown Community College	MD	Inclusive open door admissions policy; assists students with course selection based on placement and advising.48
Cape Cod Community College	MA	Open admission policy; specific transfer agreements and support for various programs.49

Conclusion: Your Journey, Your Strategy, Your Success

Let’s go back to Alex, the student who called me in a panic over his score of 19.

He didn’t let that number define him.

He used this exact framework.

He calmed his panic by understanding his score was statistically average.

He built a balanced college list, including “target” schools where his 19 was in the running and several excellent “test-optional” universities.

He chose to withhold his score from the test-optional schools and instead poured his energy into his application.

He wrote a powerful essay about a local creek cleanup project he started, weaving in his passion for environmental science.

He got glowing letters of recommendation from his science teacher and his boss at a part-time landscaping job.

The result? Alex was admitted to several fantastic universities, including a highly-regarded test-optional school with a top-tier environmental science program.

He’s thriving there today.

Your ACT score is a snapshot in time, a single key on a large keychain.

It does not define your potential or limit your future.

You now have a map to thousands of doors and a whole set of keys to open them: your score, your story, your grades, your impact, and your strategy.

You are in control of this journey.

Go open your door.

Works cited

1. 19 ACT Colleges | Page 1 – Appily.com, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.appily.com/colleges/act/19
2. What Can I Do With a 19 on the ACT? – CollegeVine, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.collegevine.com/faq/126751/what-can-i-do-with-a-19-on-the-act
3. Interpreting a 19 on the ACT – CollegeVine, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.collegevine.com/faq/27768/interpreting-a-19-on-the-act
4. 2024 Average ACT® Scores by State – Horizon Education, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://horizoneducation.com/blog/average-act-scores-by-state
5. Average 2024 ACT Test Scores by State, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.act.org/content/act/en/products-and-services/the-act/scores/average-act-test-scores-by-state.html
6. www.kaptest.com, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.kaptest.com/study/act/whats-good-act-score/#:~:text=A%20good%20ACT%20score%20is,maximum%20composite%20score%20of%2036.
7. 2024 Average ACT® Test Score by State – OnToCollege, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.ontocollege.com/average-act-test-score/
8. ACT Score Ranges Explained: Setting Your Personal College Targets – Campus Library, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://collegerover.com/campus-library/news/165/act-score-ranges
9. What’s a Good ACT Score? A Bad ACT Score? An Excellent ACT Score? – Blog PrepScholar, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://blog.prepscholar.com/what-is-a-good-act-score-a-bad-act-score-an-excellent-act-score
10. Best Colleges That Accept a 19 ACT Score | Scholarships and Admission Info – Testbook, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://testbook.com/en-us/act-exam/is-19-a-good-act-score
11. admissionsight.com, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://admissionsight.com/is-19-a-good-act-score/
12. Is 19 a Good ACT Score? Schools That Accept a 19 ACT – Learn.org, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://learn.org/articles/is_19_a_good_act_score.html
13. SAT and ACT Policies and Score Ranges for Popular Colleges and Universities, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.compassprep.com/college-profiles/
14. College Acceptance Rates for 150 Popular Schools – BestColleges.com, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.bestcolleges.com/blog/college-acceptance-rates/
15. 2025 Best Colleges with High Acceptance Rates in America – Niche, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.niche.com/colleges/search/best-colleges-high-acceptance-rates/
16. 31 ACT Colleges | Page 1 – Appily.com, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.appily.com/colleges/act/31
17. Latest Colleges & Universities topics – College Confidential Forums, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://talk.collegeconfidential.com/c/colleges-and-universities/77/none
18. ACT/SAT Optional List for Fall 2025 – Fairtest, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://fairtest.org/test-optional-list/
19. What You Need to Know About Applying Test-Optional – Admissions, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://admissions.pitt.edu/blog/applying-test-optional/
20. What is Test Optional? – BigFuture – College Board, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/plan-for-college/apply-to-college/what-is-test-optional
21. 2025–2026 Test Optional Colleges: What You Need to Know – InGenius Prep, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://ingeniusprep.com/blog/2025-2026-test-optional-colleges/
22. Top Test Optional and Test Blind Colleges 2025, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://collegesofdistinction.com/advice/best-test-optional-colleges/
23. What is Test Optional? – Fairtest, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://fairtest.org/test-optional/
24. Test Optional, Test Flexible, and Test Blind Explained! – Curvebreakers Blog, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://curvebreakerstestprep.com/test-optional-test-flexible-and-test-blind-explained/
25. ‘Test Blind’, ‘Test Optional’ or ‘Test Preferred’ – What Do These Categories Mean?, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://weilcollegeadvising.com/test-blind-test-optional-or-test-preferred-what-do-these-categories-mean/
26. admissions.pitt.edu, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://admissions.pitt.edu/blog/applying-test-optional/#:~:text=(Test%2Doptional%20schools%20differ%20from,won’t%20count%20against%20you.
27. Applying to College With Lower Stats, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.collegeadvisor.com/resources/college-apps-low-stats/
28. What We Look For in Our Applicants – Office of Admissions and Recruitment, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://admissions.wisc.edu/can-i-get-in-to-uw-madison/
29. Undergraduate Admission | UW-Milwaukee Academic Catalog, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://catalog.uwm.edu/admission-costs/undergraduate-admission/
30. Overcoming Academic Challenges Essay: How to approach it? – CollegeVine, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.collegevine.com/faq/20760/overcoming-academic-challenges-essay-how-to-approach-it
31. How to Write the Overcoming Challenges Essay + Example – College Transitions, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.collegetransitions.com/blog/overcoming-challenges-essay/
32. www.collegeraptor.com, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.collegeraptor.com/getting-in/articles/act-sat/how-to-improve-your-act-score/#:~:text=Extracurriculars%3A%20Keep%20participating%20in%20your,lower%20than%20you’d%20like.
33. How do I get into a really good college with low ACT test scores? – Career Village, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.careervillage.org/questions/864188/how-do-i-get-into-a-really-good-college-with-low-act-test-scores
34. Test Optional Colleges in 2025-2026: 50+ Schools – Ivy Coach, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.ivycoach.com/the-ivy-coach-blog/standardized-testing/test-optional-colleges-list/
35. Test-Optional Colleges 2025/26: Full List and SAT/ACT Tips – Crimson Education US, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.crimsoneducation.org/us/blog/test-optional-colleges/
36. What percentage of students who attend community college transfer to a four-year university or graduate from either one of them? – Quora, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.quora.com/What-percentage-of-students-who-attend-community-college-transfer-to-a-four-year-university-or-graduate-from-either-one-of-them
37. What do national transfer outcomes reveal, and how does North Carolina compare? – EdNC, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.ednc.org/02-08-2024-what-do-national-transfer-outcomes-reveal-and-how-does-north-carolina-compare/
38. Just 16% of community college students transfer and earn a bachelor’s degree, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.highereddive.com/news/community-college-students-transfer-bachelors-degree-completion/706773/
39. Tracking Transfer: Community College and Four-Year Institutional Effectiveness in Broadening Bachelor’s Degree Attainment, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://ccrc.tc.columbia.edu/publications/tracking-transfer-community-college-and-four-year-institutional-effectiveness-in-broadening-bachelors-degree-attainment.html
40. New Report Ranks States Based on Colleges’ Performance in Helping Students Transfer to Four-Year Universities and Earn Bachelor’s Degrees, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://ccrc.tc.columbia.edu/press-releases/new-report-ranks-states-on-colleges-performance-helping-students-transfer.html
41. Transfer Credit Evaluation – TXST Admissions – Texas State University, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.admissions.txst.edu/future-students/transfer-credit-evaluation.html
42. Transferology, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.transferology.com/
43. Transfer Credit | Texas State University, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://mycatalog.txstate.edu/undergraduate/general-information/admissions/transfer-credit/
44. Persistence: The Success of Students Who Transfer from Community Colleges to Selective Four-Year Institutions – Jack Kent Cooke Foundation, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.jkcf.org/research/persistence/
45. Admissions | Admissions | Austin Community College District, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://admissions.austincc.edu/
46. Admissions | Montcalm Community College, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.montcalm.edu/sub-header/admissions/
47. Open Access Admissions – Springfield – STCC, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.stcc.edu/apply/open-access/
48. Admissions Policy | Hagerstown Community College, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://www.hagerstowncc.edu/admissions/policy
49. Open Admissions | Cape Cod Community College, accessed on August 5, 2025, https://live-capecod.cleancatalog.io/open-admissions